Eye Stylus Shadow Stick
Waterproof. Up To 12-Hour Wear.
Thru Line Waterproof Eyeliner
Up to 24-hour color. Safe for sensitive eyes.
Earn points with this purchase.
The art of the eye—made easy. Curate your everyday look with The Art of the Eye Trio—a customizable edit of clean, long-wear eyeshadow, eyeliner, and mascara.
Paint
Prime your canvas with an all-over wash of Renaissance-inspired shadow. Choose your favorite matte or shimmer shade of Eye Stylus Shadow Stick for rich, waterproof pigment that blends easily and lasts up to 12 hours. With a versatile slanted tip, it’s easy to be playful or precise—use the flat side for a wash of all-over color, or the edge to line, define, and brighten.
Sketch
Line and define lids with Thru Line Waterproof Eyeliner, a long-wear formula that’s safe for sensitive eyes and the waterline. Thru Line is waterproof, sweatproof, and glides on smoothly without dragging, skipping, or tugging. The rich, saturated color blends effortlessly for diffused definition, then sets for up to 24-hour wear. Choose your favorite among 10 art-inspired shades, from nuanced neutrals to dimensional jewel tones.
Frame
Frame your work of art with long, lifted lashes. Choose between soft black or rich chocolate brown Limitless Lash—Sephora’s #1 mascara for a reason.* The award-winning formula lengthens, lifts, and separates lashes without clumping—plus is safe for sensitive eyes and contact lens wearers.
*Source: YipitData, U.S. Sephora Mascara Omnichannel Sales ($), SKU Rank, Jan-Dec 2025.
- Laura F.Verified ReviewerReviewingThru Line Waterproof EyelinerI recommend this productSkin Type CombinationSkin Tone NeutralUndertone OliveEye Color BrownAge Range 35-44Reviewed by An incentivized reviewerReviewed By An incentivized reviewerThru Line Waterproof Eyeliner FlourishRated 4 out of 5 stars7/26/26Smooth Application
I received this eye liner to try at no cost through PinchMe. I really like the color (Flourish) and I really liked that it applied really smoothly with very little pressure. It blended well in my eye corners. It has some great staging power once it's set, keeping a neat line on my lash line for 9 hours Unfortunately, as soon as I put it on, my nose got runny and my eyes started watering. Once I took some allergy meds, this went away. I think it's a very nice product, but depending on sensitivity may not be the best choice for everyone. I will continue to use this, I will just take some allergy meds ahead of doing my makeup. I have not sharpened it yet and hope it holds up well when it's needed.
- Mary K.Verified ReviewerReviewingThru Line Waterproof EyelinerI recommend this productSkin Type CombinationSkin Tone NeutralUndertone OliveEye Color GreenAge Range 35-44Reviewed by An incentivized reviewerReviewed By An incentivized reviewerThru Line Waterproof Eyeliner AbstractRated 5 out of 5 stars7/24/26Compliments My eye color
I got this as a free product sample from pinch Me. I absolutely love the Abstract color in this eyeliner because it really compliments My green eyes. It goes on smooth, and did not smudge even in the high heat and humidity that e have been having in PA recently.
- TinaVerified ReviewerReviewingThru Line Waterproof EyelinerI recommend this productSkin Type CombinationSkin Tone OliveUndertone NeutralEye Color BrownAge Range 45-54Reviewed by An incentivized reviewerReviewed By An incentivized reviewerThru Line Waterproof Eyeliner SerifRated 5 out of 5 stars7/22/26Waterproof eyeliner
I received the ILIA thru line waterproof eyeliner free from PINCHme in exchange for my honest opinion. I received the color serif. This eyeliner glides on so smooth no tugging and lasts all day. I love that this eyeliner washes off easily. The color is a beautiful deep brown color almost black looking. The deepest brown color I love it.
- LeeVerified ReviewerReviewingThru Line Waterproof EyelinerI recommend this productSkin Type CombinationSkin Tone NeutralUndertone CoolEye Color GreenAge Range 35-44Reviewed by An incentivized reviewerReviewed By An incentivized reviewerThru Line Waterproof Eyeliner HyperrealRated 4 out of 5 stars7/22/26ILIA eyeliner in Hyperreal
I received a full sized ILIA Thru Line Waterproof Eyeliner in Hyperreal with Up to 24-Hour Wear from Pinchme in exchange for my honest review. I love the color it works perfectly on the waterline. The eyeliner is nice and glides on smooth. All in all highly recommend!
- KimVerified ReviewerReviewingThru Line Waterproof EyelinerI recommend this productSkin Type DrySkin Tone WarmUndertone WarmEye Color BrownAge Range 55-64Reviewed by An incentivized reviewerReviewed By An incentivized reviewerThru Line Waterproof Eyeliner InkRated 5 out of 5 stars7/22/26Easy glide, very little smudging
I received the color Ink to review as a promotion and I tested it over a number of days. I tightline because I have downturned eyes which tend to water and I wanted to test this out in real life. The eyeliner goes on very smoothly and didn’t tug at my eye. It also was gentle and didn’t irritate my eyes. I wore it for over 8 hours and had a little smudging at the outer corner of my eyes which was great! It did take a good eye makeup remover to get it completely off too. Extremely smooth formula, no scent and no eye irritation even so close to my eye. Definite recommend from me.
